One Document, Many Designers
Dividing a multipage document into multiple documents of one or more pages each and then collecting the pieces under a book file is a common collaboration workflow. So common is it that I’ve given it a name–the Book File Collaboration Workflow (I hope no one has already coined this). Under this method, members of the design team work on pieces of the whole, and each piece is at least one full page. If the team members work from a single network file repository, each piece of the publication stays in synch with all other pieces with regard to section and page numbering, style consistency, and other shared document attributes. If they don’t work off the network, shared attributes are updated when their pages are delivered to the person in charge of assembling and managing the parts into a whole publication (the paginator).
Setting Up the Book File Collaboration Workflow
To set up book file collaboration, begin by analyzing the document to be created or edited. How many creatives will work on it? Does it have inherent break points for apportionment? For instance, if the publication is a magazine, could the “Letter from the Editor†column page be broken out into its own document for one designer to work on while the “New Bites†spread and subsequent department and features pages are given their own documents and handed to other designers? If logical content separators aren’t as obvious, look for more subtle separations where the document could be divided.
Once you’ve identified where the publication can be separated, make the pieces.
- Begin with the complete publication in a single document. Set on the master page(s) folios, page headers and footers, and any other common elements that will appear on all or at least the majority of the document’s pages. Although you’re unlikely to need the full publication document again, save it for safety anyway.
- On the Pages panel (Window > Pages), select all the pages that will not be in the first constituent part and delete them. You should then have a document containing only the page(s) that will be assigned to the first designer. The pages must be contiguous; if you want to give pages 2–5 and 10–15 to the same team member, make one document for pages 2–5 and another for 10–15.
If the document contains the Current Page Number special character, the document pages will renumber after the other pages are deleted. Ignore the page numbers. They’ll be fixed automatically in a few steps.
If you manually insert page numbers, stop doing that! InDesign has robust section and page numbering options that can handle nearly any page enumeration scenario with far less work than the unnecessarily masochistic practice of manually inserting and changing page numbers. Read about page numbers, section numbering, and text variables in this book before you say, Oh, InDesign won’t do automatically what I need for page numbering and identification.
- Because you’re still working in the one and only full publication document and you’ve probably just deleted the majority of the publication, don’t save. Instead, choose File > Save a Copy. When prompted, name the document something both you and the designer who will work on it will understand. If the section you’re creating is the first of 10 parts of the May issue, a name like May-p2‑5.indd would be ideal. Click OK when ready. Save a Copy saves a copy of the document without saving or closing the original document.
- Press Cmd+Z/Ctrl+Z to undo the deletion of pages and return to the full document.
- Repeat steps 1 through 4 for each subsequent section of the document, saving a copy of each part, until all the pieces are saved out to their own documents.
- Go to File > New > Book and create a new InDesign book INBK file with the same name as your publication. After you save, a blank Book panel will appear; its name will be that of your publication.
- On the Book panel’s flyout menu, choose Add Documents. In the Add Documents dialog, choose all the publication part files you just created. Click on the first file in the list to select it, and then, holding the Shift key (on both Mac and Windows), click on the last file in the list. All interceding documents will also be selected. Click the Open button and the documents will populate the Book panel.
- If the documents are not in their correct order, drag them within the list until they are correct. Automatic page numbers will update across all the files, putting them back into place in the scheme of the overall document.
- Send the section documents to the designers who will be responsible for them.
Using the Book panel, you, as the publication manager, will be in control of the overall publication cohesion. If your team is working from a network file server, place all the component documents, the INBK book file, and documents’ linked assets in a folder on the server, and have team members open from, and save to, the same documents and folder. Your view of the publication through the Book panel will then always be in synch with the most recently saved changes to any pages of the publication. If your team works remotely from one another or for another reason cannot open and save files in a central repository, ensure that, as each piece comes back to you, you overwrite originals with new versions, which will also keep your Book panel updated.
Rearranging the individual documents in the publication is as easy as dragging them within the Book panel. If section A, for instance, must now come after C instead of before section B, simply drag A down to the correct place in the Book panel. Pages throughout the rest of the publication will instantly renumber to reflect the change. You don’t even need to involve the designer working on section A!
If you later need to make changes to the segments, to move pages between publication sections for instance, that’s easy:
- Open both the source and destination documents by double-clicking each in the Book panel.
- In the source document, the one from which pages will be moved, choose Layout > Pages > Move Pages, which will open the Move Pages dialog (see Figure 12.1).
Figure 12.1 The Move Pages dialog
- In the Move Pages dialog and the Move Pages field, enter the page number(s) of the page(s) to move from the source document to the target document. Use hyphen-separated numbers to specify a range (e.g., 1–3) and comma-separated numbers for nonsequential pages (e.g., 1,3). Change the Move To field from Current Document to the name of the destination document, and then, using the two Destination fields, tell InDesign precisely where to drop the page(s). Check Delete Pages After Moving so they will be removed from the source document.
When you click OK, the pages will immediately move from the source to the target document. Save both, and you’re done; the Book panel will update itself.
If you only want to copy pages between documents, leaving the originals in the source document but also adding them to the target, don’t check Delete Pages After Moving. This is a handy trick for those situations wherein someone comes along and says, “Hey! Wouldn’t it be cool if every chapter suddenly began with a splash page?†Folks who work on magazines, telephone directories, and other such advertising-supported periodicals love that particular trick because it makes it easy to insert newly sold full-page or full-spread ads into the middle of a feature article or other publication section that can’t–or shouldn’t–be broken into still more documents.
Speaking of periodicals…
Next: When Book File Collaboration Won’t Work
This, in my opinion is ridiculous!
Design by committee to the unth degree. Having been in publishing for almost 20 years, I have yet to experience a scenario where the most time and cost efficient way of doing things is to have several designers working on the same FILE at the same time.
What Adobe seems to leave out of their vision of ‘workflow’ is the customer – you know, the people that pay people like us so they can change their minds at the drop of a hat.
Sure, one application may work, but five personalities working harmoniously at the same time – that’s a joke.
Simultaneous concept development… never works.
My mind’s eye envisions a server bulging with dupes of pages and folders from people who are, for a lack of a better word… in a state of flux.
Sorry, this seems like a poor man’s version of Composition Zones. Last time I checked in Quark 7 you simply selected an area, a page, a spread or a section of a document you wanted to “farm out” and with a little bit of practice, anyone on the network or Internet (if invited) automatically gets a document with only their bits editible. Upon saving, your grayed out areas then update. It’s a lot different when software is designed specifically for colaboration as Quark 7 and 8 are, as opposed to the Rube Goldberg approach which has been available for years already. BTW: Our customers who use this are growing and would never go back to not using it. It’s like taking processors out of your Xeon chip…parallel processing is where it’s at.
I like the little comment boxes, they are nice. :)
No matter how you look at it, cool collaboration tools in Quark are useless if you are still stuck with a lame layout application.